Todd Beyerlein competed for Carmel High School from 1993 to 1997 in both the high jump and long jump. His personal best of 7-1 1/2 was set in 1997. Beyerlein won the IHSAA State Finals in 1996 at 6-8 and repeated in 1997 at 7-0 and won a variety of meets outside the state, including the Junior Olympics and the South Pacific Games held in Fiji.